ASK Musings

No matter where you go, there you are.



April 2014



DK Eyewitness Travel Guide to New Orleans by Marilyn Wood

Written by , Posted in Adventures, Reviews

Three Stars

DK New Orleans

First off, I fully recognize that this review would probably be best saved for AFTER I visit the city for which I purchased it. However, that trip is over five months away, so I don’t know if I’d really remember much at that point. If anything in the book has led me wildly astray, however, I’ll come back and update my review.

In my experience of the travel book world, there are a few big players, which I usually envision this way: Rick Steves (a.k.a. what your parents use); Fodor’s and Frommer’s (the sort of generic middle of the road); Lonely Planet (for the SLIGHTLY less mainstream traveler), and Eyewitness (for the person who likes shiny things and detailed maps). I know there are others; these are just the ones I have found to be the ones usually in stock at a bookstore. In looking at my husband’s and my travel bookshelf, we have 10 Lonely Planet guides and three Eyewitness Travel.

I chose the Eyewitness version of a New Orleans guide for a couple of reasons: this was the one with the newest edition, I’m a sucker for the photos and neighborhood maps, and we weren’t in need of accommodation recommendations, as our travelling companions had already found and booked us a place via AirBnB. And as an aside – I rarely find myself using the accommodations sections of travel books anymore. For our honeymoon, we did look at some of the recommendations, but then checked on trip advisor to see if there were any glaring problems with them.

This guide mostly met my expectations – it has good descriptions of different areas, and provides about 30 pages of history and overview of the area. As with most travel books, this one is broken down by general neighborhoods, and features the big highlights. A lot of the items are homes that are worth a look but are closed to the public, which on the one hand is kind of cool – it’s a good idea for where to wander if you enjoy looking at architecture as I do – but I don’t recall a guide book that devoted so much space to places you can look at but can’t go inside to visit. While we likely won’t be travelling outside of the city while there (we’re only in town from Friday night through Tuesday night), the book also includes 25 pages on areas outside of New Orleans, including Baton Rouge.

The biggest drawback to this guide, in my opinion, is actually the language used in some of the descriptions. I mean, the Civil War and history of slavery is mentioned at times (and the Confederacy is, I won’t way glorified, but monuments to the military ‘heroes’ certainly aren’t pointed out as problematic), but the author fails to mention what went on at these giant “beautiful” plantations. I think it’s kind of gross to go on about the “glories” accumulated by plantation owners without addressing the fact that they had all that money because they didn’t pay their laborers. The author also uses some questionable language – for example she uses the term mulatto, which, come on now. It would have only taken up a couple more characters to say ‘multi-racial,’ or a sentence to explain why that word was used (perhaps it was a term that meant something different in that context? Hard to say). It was sort of like seeing an Asian person referred to as an ‘Oriental’ – it’s just wrong and I feel like the editors should have caught that.

I would assume they are marketing these guides to the traveler who doesn’t want to think about these things (“I’m on vacation! I don’t want to worry about the problematic issues of slavery and such.”), but to me that’s disingenuous. I don’t think it would really be such a challenge to be more culturally sensitive, and not just ignore the realities of the history of the place.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *